Horror Movie Reviews

More Details... Price: $39.98

Title: TCM Archives - The Lon Chaney Collection (The Ace of Hearts / Laugh (0) Starring: Lon Chaney, Leatrice Joy, John Bowers, Hardee Kirkland, and Raymond Hatton Director: Array Rating: Unrated Runtime: 325 minutes Avg. Score: 5 Submit Comment Hits: 7

Review of TCM Archives - The Lon Chaney Collection (The Ace of Hearts / Laugh, Clown, Laugh / The Unknown)

[ Back to Homepage | Back to Horror Movie Reviews Index ]

HellHorror.com not responsible for reviews/comments and they may be removed at any time.

Submit Comment

Comments for TCM Archives - The Lon Chaney Collection (The Ace of Hearts / Laugh

• Posted on 2008-06-21
  A good first look at Lon Chaney's work
  
  Most people associate Lon Chaney as a star of horror films, but he was much more than that. This collection offers three of Chaney's films with commentary, a stills recreation of the lost film "London after Midnight", and a documentary on Chaney's life and work.
  
  The oldest film in the bunch, "Ace of Hearts", was directed by Wallace Worsley, the same man who directed Chaney in the more famous "The Penalty" and "The Hunchback of Notre Dame". Here Chaney is the member of a group of men who decide that a certain prominent man poses a threat to society and thus has "lived too long". They draw cards to decide who will do the deed. Both Chaney and the man who draws the ace of hearts - indicating he is chosen - are in love with Lillith, another member of the group. This is a straight dramatic role for Chaney, and a pretty good film. Outside of his longer hair, which the commentator said was unusual for the times, there is nothing out of the ordinary about his appearance. There is some overacting by all of the players, which is probably due to direction.
  
  "Laugh Clown Laugh" has Chaney playing an Italian clown who finds a baby girl in the forest. He names her Simonetta, and cares for her as a father. However, when she grows up, Chaney begins to love her as a woman. He is unable to tell her because of his role as father figure in her life. As a result he cannot stop crying. A wealthy young man cares for her too, as a result of his love he cannot stop laughing. This film is somewhat similar to "He Who Gets Slapped" as far as Chaney being the man who sacrifices everything for love when he realizes the girl loves someone else.
  
  The best film is "The Unknown". Here you get a view of Chaney the villain and the man of a thousand bodies. He is Alonzo the Armless, a performer in a circus, in love with the circus owner's daughter, Nanon (Joan Crawford). He actually does have arms. He is just hiding them for the purpose of hiding from the police, since he is a criminal who is known to have two thumbs on one hand. Naturally, nobody is going to suspect an armless man. Nanon feels safe with Alonzo since she hates having men put their arms around her. How far will Alonzo go to gain Nanon? This film is directed by Tod Browning, who worked so well with Chaney.
  
  The stills recreation of the lost film "London After Midnight" was done quite well with very good atmospheric music added. Chaney's vampire does look a little unconventional though, and it's too bad we have not even clips of this one since some people who actually saw the movie said that the most unusual thing about Lon Chaney's vampire was his walk. Apparently it was much like Groucho Marx' famous gait. That's something that stills, no matter how well presented, just can't communicate. One thing I noted after viewing - the plot for 1935's "The Mark of the Vampire" was almost completely lifted from this film. Both were directed by Tod Browning.
  
  The commentary on all of the films are very good, and so is the extensive documentary on Chaney's life. There are more Chaney films in control of WHV that I would also like to see put on DVD - most notably "Tell it to the Marines", which was Chaney's favorite film and one that got him made an honorary marine. As the documentary stated, Chaney's popularity with movie audiences is hard to figure. Undoubtedly he had talent, but he was not a particularly good looking leading man in a conventional sense. His power at the box office probably had something to do with his ability to gain empathy from the audience no matter what role he took on, no matter how disfigured, no matter how villainous.
  Score: 5
• Posted on 2007-08-23
  Not much to add to previous reviews...
  
  ...only that, believe it or not, Lon Chaney in Germany is a complete unknown to today's audiences.
  Whenever I mention the name to people around me (even true movie buffs) I am confronted with complete ignorance...Lon, who???
  It is a shame that this great actor never found the recognition in this country, where during the silent era real motion picture history was written. Just imagine, how a collaboration between true artists such as Chaney and for instance Fritz Lang could have looked like!
  But I guess this is just wishful thinking...
  Let's instead enjoy this package we have here. Despite offering a mixed bag (with The Ace of Hearts for me providing a rather lame start), this box set contains two really exciting displays of Chaney's unbelievable talent. Laugh, Clown, Laugh is a deeply romantic story with Chaney acting as the too old and hence unwanted lover of a young artist. A movie that despite its rather simple plot but at the same time due to Chaney's amazing acting qualities offers a truly touching story, that if brought to the screen today would still find its audience.
  The Unknown, the last and without any doubt the best movie of the three, offers a story that even under today's standards (and I am talking bizarre and blood stained movies such as Saw and alike) should thrill genre fans. For it proves that despite its bizarre if not sadistic contents the ACTING makes for a great movie experience. Chaney alone carries the twisted plot about a sideshow artist become cripple for his love of his life, just to find out that loves goes in a very different way...so, if you are into the cinema of the bizarre, and the cinema of great acting performances, you better sink your teeth into this one!
  
  Score: 5
• Posted on 2007-06-12
  Great value set for the enthusiast
  
  TCM have produced a great set of rare Lon Chaney silent films which will appeal to the Chaney fan and anyone interested in the history of the American film. The set consists of 3 films which were "lost" for many years, so it is great they are now available to view.
  
  Michael Blake is the author of 3 books on Chaney and provides detailed commentaries on each film. Blake has clearly devoted his life to Chaney's legacy and his commentaries go way beyond what is seen on the screen. Accordingly, they are very interesting but possibly jaundiced about the films' appeal 80 years later.
  
  The earliest film, from 1921, is "Ace of Hearts" a static and melodramatic story of a vigilante group who draw cards to select who will commit murder. The print is fairly poor and the film suffers from a snail pace and overacting.
  
  The second film is "The Unknown", released in 1927. The film, we are told, is possibly the best of the partnership of the director Tod Browning with Chaney. The story is bizarre, the powerful story of a circus performer who cuts off his arms to win the girl. Joan Crawford, in a very early role, plays the object of Chaney's love. The film follows the common theme of unrequited love which appeared in many of Chaney's films. As well as observing Chaney's art, the film has excellent photography and Crawford is very different to the pretentious star she became, suggesting more talent than she subsequently showed. She also displays a rawness which is probably much closer to who she was before she became THE Joan Crawford.
  
  The final film is "Laugh Clown Laugh", apparantly Chaney's own favourite of all his films. Once again, the film's theme is unrequited love with Chaney as a clown who makes the public laugh while he is heartbroken inside. This time, the object of his affection is the virginal and teenage Loretta Young and she displays the purity of emotion which was in all of her best performances pre 1935 long before the artificial later Loretta.
  
  There is also a reconstruction of an early version of the vampyr legend, 'London after Midnight". This is a highly desired lost film but on the evidence of a few interviewees who saw the original film, the script and the stills, it looks like it might have been extremely melodramatic. While the reconstruction has been done lovingly, the result is static and rather boring, which is to be expected, I suppose.
  
  Both "Laugh Clown Laugh" and "The Unknown" are missing scenes but what remains preserves Chaney at the height of his powers. They demonstrate that, in fact, his reputation as a horror star is misleading. He was a character actor who changed his appearance to suit the role in the same way as Charles Laughton and Paul Muni did much later. His talent for pathos is outstanding.
  
  Possibly the best features of the DVD set are the marvellous documentary about Chaney and the short films about the competitions which TCM ran to locate new scores for the films. The DVD set is excellent value.
  Score: 4
• Posted on 2007-02-11
  When Will We See The Second Chaney Collection?
  
  I bought this set right away in October 2003. It has been over three years since this set was released. It includes great performances by Lon Chaney Sr. WHEN are we going to get a second collection? I personally would love to see "The Unholy Three," both the 1925 silent version and the 1930 talkie version released as part of a second collection, and also "West of Zanzibar," and maybe "The Road To Mandalay." This great performer deserves another release of his best and I for one will show up for my DVD collection the day it is released!
  Score: 5
• Posted on 2006-09-24
  When was Lon NOT great?
  
  Contained in this wonderful collection are the films 'The Ace of Hearts' (1921), 'The Unknown' (1927), and 'Laugh, Clown, Laugh' (1928), together with an awesome documentary about Lon's life and career (with ample film clips), a 40-minute stills and intertitle recreation of 'London After Midnight' (1927), audio commentaries by Michael Blake, Lon Chaney's definitive biographer, photo galleries, introductions to the films by TCM host Robert Osbourne, and a featurette on the composers who have won TCM's now-annual Young Film Composers contest. Two of those silents that were selected to have new scores written for them by the winners were 'The Ace of Hearts' and 'Laugh, Clown, Laugh.'
  
  'The Ace of Hearts' was the first of Lon's films I ever saw, and even though it's not really the height of greatness, it did make me into a big fan. The origins and purpose of this secret society which Lon belongs to are never really explained (we just have a vague idea of their purpose), and the plot was also a bit of a mystery. However, as curious and under-par though this film might be, Lon totally steals the show. He just *looked* like an actor, and lived up to all of the great things I'd heard about what a wonderful actor he was. I was really impressed by his body language and facial expressions, and how he just inspired such sympathy in the audience, wanting him to be the one to get the girl (the beautiful Leatrice Joy) and to have a happy ending.
  
  'The Unknown' is bizarre, to say the least. It was directed by Tod Browning, his favorite director, who did a lot of macabre disturbing unconventional pictures like this. It also seems as though there's some footage missing from this one, at only about 50 minutes long, added to the fact that it was only available in murky 9.5 mm black market copies until 1968, when it was discovered, along with some other films, in France, in cans labeled "l'inconnu" (i.e., "unknown"). What remains is really good, however. Alonzo is a supposedly armless knife thrower in love with his beautiful assistant Nanon (Joan Crawford), who is afraid and distrustful of men with arms. We're never really told just why she's so afraid of a man who could put his arms around her, but one suspects that she was raped or abused in the past. However, as we come to find out, Alonzo does have his arms, only he's hiding them so that Nanon will love and trust him. He's also hiding them because he has double thumbs, and the police are looking for him for some crimes he's committed, knowing only that it was a man with the same condition. Things take a turn for the worst when Nanon sees him from the back strangling her father (though luckily she doesn't see his face), and the life-altering decision Alonzo makes is not only incredibly disturbing, unthinkable, and creepy, but also leaves the door open for the handsome strong man in their travelling circus, Malabar (Norman Kerry), to move in on Nanon, who has always pushed away his romantic overtures. When Alonzo comes back to the circus after taking care of his bizarre business, things get even creepier. Once again Lon makes you feel sympathy for this strange character, someone you'd ordinarily feel repulsed and horrified by.
  
  'Laugh, Clown, Laugh' is a truly touching and heartbreaking film, and came out in the last really great year for silents, by which time the artform had truly reached its peak and been beautifully perfected. It is rather disturbing how Lon's character, Tito the clown, develops romantic feelings for Simonetta (Loretta Young) when she becomes a young woman, even though he and his partner Simon have been raising her as practically their own daughter since they found her abandoned when she was just a toddler, but you get the feeling that deep down he realises how wrong and foolish these feelings are, not only because she's like a daughter to him, but also because he's an older man, and doesn't have anything to promise her the way her much younger and more handsome suitor Count Luigi (Nils Asther) does. A famous story about the filming of this movie is that the director, Herbert Brenon, was often quite rude and mean to Loretta Young, who was just a teenager at the time and barely starting her career. However, he was always civil to her whenever Lon was around, and after he picked up on this, he was with her constantly, even when they were shooting scenes he didn't appear in, guiding, directing, and mentoring her, and protecting her from the abusive director.
  
  The stills recreation of 'London After Midnight' is alright, but doesn't really deliver a big punch due to the lack of actual film footage that might speed the story along better or make it seem more compelling and interesting. If only there had been even some surviving footage to pad out the stills with, as in the recreations of 'The Young Rajah' and the four-hour version of 'Greed.' This film has long been among the holy grail of missing silents, ever since the last known surviving print was destroyed by a vault fire at MGM in 1967. However, people who saw it in its original run and even as "recently" as the Fifties or Sixties have usually been quoted as saying that it wasn't all that great, and that the people so desperate to find it would probably feel the same way if they had had a chance to see it. Perhaps this is a classic case of something being elevated to high status due to the reputations of Chaney and Browning and the fact that it's lost and no longer able to be judged on its true merits. As sad as it is that an overwhelming amount of silents were lost, both within their own lifetimes and in the ensuing decades, not all lost films were great works of art that modern-day people would be really impressed by and enamoured of. Just like with modern-day movies, most silents too were just fun lightweight date movies or something for a rainy day, not epic timeless classic masterpieces or movies that are so good you want to watch them over and over again.
  
  Overall, this is a great collection. Lon was great in every film he was in, even lacklustre efforts. His mere presence could elevate something that would have appeared only ordinary or even bad had some other actor been in it. His growing up with Deaf-mute parents played a big part in how he was so skilled at pantomimic acting, in making the viewer feel sympathy and empathy with characters whom they ordinarily would have walked on by or spat on in disgust or fear, and the stories about how he had keen empathy in real life for people who were different are also legendary. This small sampling of films is compelling proof of just why he was one of the 20th century's greatest male film actors.
  Score: 5